Home About FSASH-SPASH Stop Child Labour Activities Schedule Photo Gallery Magasine  Contacts

 

 

MANUAL

COMMITTMENT OF EDUCATION TRADE UNIONS,
TEACHERS AND OTHER STAKEHOLDERS TO REDUCE
DROPOUT FROM SCHOOL AND ELIMINATE CHILD LABOUR

 

It is almost accepted by all of us that child labour is an issue of great concern for many countries of the world, including our country.

According to the definition of respective International Conventions, child labour encompasses all kinds of work, which as to their nature and conditions, are harmful to child’s health, his/her physical, mental, moral and social development and hinder his/her education.

ILO’s (International Labour Organization) trustful data show that around 215 million of children are actually working. 115 million of them work directly in very dangerous jobs, being physically, mentally and morally damaged. 53 million of them are of the age from 5 to 14 years old and 62 million others are of the age from 15 to 17 years old. 60% of  working children are engaged in agricultural sector, where only one in five gets paid, while others are engaged in family work.

Child labour is a very concerning issue for our country, as well.
There are about 40 thousand children working on national level. Partial studies show that around 8 thousand children work on the street, as street vendors, (selling cigarettes and other items, or at car wash etc), other 4-5 thousand children work at light industry, particularly at clothing and shoe industry, while 12-14 thousand children work in more dangerous jobs like construction and other sectors, including agriculture, mainly within family framework.

Poverty, lack of social protection, informal economy, low cost of child labour, parents mentality, habits and behavior of certain groups of people, problems related to education system, as well as the insufficient effectiveness of the work done by governmental and social stakeholders, including trade unions, are some of the main causes of child labour on global and domestic level.

Child labour is very harmful to children themselves and causes great damages to adults’ future and society development in general.
According to the United Nations and ILO Conventions, the minimum age for employment is 16 years old and employment of children under this age is considered as a violation of their rights. Meanwhile, Albanian Labour Code defines that “Only adults over 18 years old can be employed in difficult and dangerous jobs for their health and personality”.
Children engagement in working under defined employment age, hinders them from growing up properly, affects them morally and hinders both their education and preparation for the future.
In addition, child labour favours poverty and is a direct threat to economic development and adults’ employment. It is a well known fact that poverty is one of the main causes of child labour, but, on the other hand, child labour itself is one of the causes of poverty. If children do adults’ work, it becomes a threat to their wages and working conditions, as well as to economic and progressive development of the entire society.
It is for this reason, that elimination of child labour is actually included in the agenda of many international institutions, governments, social partners and civil society.                                                                

The main slogan of institutions, organizations and associations involved in the elimination of child labour is: “Childhood means learning and not working. Let’s leave children learn and parents work”
Among the most important Millennium Development Goals, defined by the United Nations and the International Community at the World Forum on Education, held in Senegal in 2000, are those related to education:                                                              

Target 2: Ensure that, by 2015, children everywhere, boys and girls alike, will be able to complete a full course of primary schooling.                                                                           

Target 3: Eliminate gender disparity in primary and secondary education, preferably by 2005, and in all levels of education no later than 2015.


The following are some of the most important steps to be taken to this aim:                                                                                                                                    

  1. Eradication of extreme poverty and elimination of hunger through the creation of new jobs for adults,
  2. Providing free and qualitative education for all children, paying special attention to females’ education,
  3. Eliminating child labour and providing access to education and training,
  4. Strengthening of laws related to prevention and elimination of child labour and their education according to international standards,
  5. Raising public awarness as to child labour prevention.

Some of the partners involved with these issues argue that child labour is a problem that should be solved by the governments. As a matter of fact, child labour has got many aspects and there are very complex reasons for its existence, hence we cannot expect only governmental organs and institutions to solve this big problem.
This problem can be solved only through efforts and comittment of many partners, including trade unions, which play an important role to this issue.

It is accepted by almost all of us, that child labour is a very important trade union issue. This is due to:

First of all, Child Labour favors informal sector
Everywhere in the world and particularly in the developing countries, informal sector is increasing day by day. It is precisely here that child labour develops more. For the trade unions this sector is very difficult to deal with. Hence, their leaders should learn more about informality in economy, in order to preserve their membership and performing power.

Child Labour damages the negotiating power of trade unions                                           
Working children represent a very rich source of low cost work. It affects the reduction of wages and weakens trade unions’ ability to negotiate about increasing wages and improving working conditions of their members.

Child Labour affects adult’s unemployment
Because of lower payment, a child may be working in a sector where an adult should be working. If children are taken off work and trained, the job might be done by an adult. There are many cases when parents are unemployed, while their children are working. This is not worth for both of them, since it is the opposite of what should happen in reality.

Solidarity and justice principles are trade union’s real foundations
Trade unions are founded to give joint power to workers to fight against injustice, prevent exploitation and require better and equal working conditions. Hence, it is the duty of trade unions to assist the creation of a social climate which will contribute to the elimination of child labour, as a concrete expression of injustice and exploitation.
Trade unions are the institutions which discover and denounce child labour on local, national and international level. They may become useful advocates for the protection of children against exploitation and abuses at the working place, by denouncing and giving evidence of concrete cases of child labour and its impacts. Trade unions can and should struggle for workers’s rights as to adequate wages, aiming at reducing the number of poor families depending on child labour.
Trade unions have various opportunities how to communicate with a greater number of adult workers and their families. They can deal with issues related to the importance of education of their children, protect them against job risks and under age employment. Being a potencial pressure force, trade unions should play an important role in the negotiations for the collective agreements and make great efforts to mobilize the society on national and international level.
Trade unions try to protect working children, support their right for education, and require the acknowlegment of adults’ rights for an adequate job and better wages.

Among all trade unions of various branches and professions, education trade unions play an important role in this direction.
They operate at schools, where they have a direct impact on pupils who are in the dilema of either going on with studies or dropping out.
Trustful sources reveal that about 70% of working children belong to the dropping out group and most of the remaining 30%  are formally attending the school, facing difficulties as to comprehension of teaching programs.
Since school drop out is the first step towards employment, our education trade unions, FSASH and SPASH, have engaged a great number of their members, teachers and activists, to deal directly with this concerning issue aiming to keep children at school.
They, through their work and example, are exercising pressure on school administration, on the Ministry of Education and Science and other state institutions to deal with this very serious issue.
Our education trade unions are also inciting other branches trade unions and organizations of civil society etc, to undertake concrete actions as to prevention and elimination of child labour.

In this process, both our trade unions, FSASH and SPASH, have been committed and have gained a precious experience in their struggle for the prevention and elimination of child labour.

They started to deal directly with this important issue during 1998-2000 and, after 8-9 years of trade union experience, consolidation of their structures and involvement with protection of social-economic interests of their members and teachers in general, it might be considered as the second phase of our trade unions development.

During the period 1998-2000, they were engaged within the frame of International Confederation of Trade Unions, ICTU, and Education International, EI, programs. Since 2000 and onward they have established a very fruitful cooperation with the Dutch Trade Unions, AOb/FNV and with ILO-IPEC.                                                                              
FSASH held a special Congress in December 2002, where very important decisions were made as to expansion of trade union activities and strengthening of its role for further development of education system in Albania, supporting progressive reforms and especially for effective commitment in keeping pupils in school, reducing drop outs as well as preventing and eliminating child labour.                                                                                                                                                                                                    Later on, at its third Congress, held in November 2004, FSASH approved a special Resolution about the engagement of its structures and teachers in general, for reducing drop outs, as well as preventing and eliminating child labour.
SPASH, as well, has approved and implemented very important programs during this period.

During 2002-2011, being supported by Dutch Trade Unions, AOb and FNV, both our trade unions were focused on six districts in the country, where these problems were most evident and there were greater opportunities for a more efficient work, such as Tirana (Bathore area), Fieri, Elbasani, Shkodra, Korca and Durresi.

Over 2 400 teachers were engaged within the framework of these projects to work individually with 4500-5000 pupils, who were the target of concrete monitoring work inside the classroom, family, community etc.
Over 1 800 pupils returned back to school during this period, while over 4 200 others have been rescued from dropping out the school. The individual work has been the basis of actions effectiveness and good results reached so far.

Very fruitful has been the combination of trainings about international employment standards and child protection, assisted by lecturers and specialists from Dutch Trade Unions, AOb and FNV, with concrete actions undertaken for the reduction of drop outs and returning working children back to school.

Of great importance was the involvement of these children in artistic, sportive and cultural activities. Such experience is being consolidated particularly at those schools and districts where AOb/FNV projects were implemented, or supported by EI and ILO-IPEC.

Within the frame of these projects, FSASH and SPASH made great efforts to involve some other branche trade unions from both Confederations, KSSH and BSPSH, (textile, handicrafts, agriculture, construction, light industry, commerce trade unions, etc.) for prevention and elimination of child labour.

In order to strengthen collaboration among these trade unions, various seminars, round tables, national conferences etc, were organized and many action plans were developed and put into action. Nevertheless, there is still much to be done for working in the same front in the future to reach the same objectives and coordinate joint ativities.

 

The comittment for creating Child Labour Free Zones

“Child Labour Free Zone” is an advanced concept related to elimination of child labour.   A Child Labour Free Zone is where:
-  No child is employed in jobs that harm his/her health and moral and hinder their education  and his/her normal growth,
- All children are enrolled and attend the compulsory education system, (nine year).

To reach this objective, both programs and projects involve all stakeholders of a certain area, such as teachers, pupils and parents, various community groups, organs of local government, other interested non-governmental organizations etc.

Actually, there are under way only pilot programs or projects, which serve as examples that should be enlarged and used to reach the set objectives for building a child labour free society.
The following are three examples from our experience:

Levani, first semester of 2010, supported by FNV, Holland

Levani comune in Fieri district is a very poor rural area, with a high presence of Roma people.

There is a secondary school (“Dino Ismaili” school), with 464 pupils, 20 of which had dropped out and started working. In addition, there were other 94 pupils, out of which 58 females, mainly from Roma community, who were at risk of dropping out, (who used to miss some classes, days or even weeks at school).
Within the frame of this Project, we defined concrete objectives for working individually with all the 20 pupils who had dropped out and were working, aiming at returning them all back to school. At the same time, we intended to work with all the 94 pupils who were at risk of dropping out, almost all of them from Roma community, rescuing them from droping out, by integrating and helping how to improve their results at school.

Efficient monitoring groups were operating for the implementation of this Project, involving more than 60 teachers, pupils, parents, representatives of trade unions, Roma community, local government and Regional Education Directorate, which all together were committed to reach the Project objectives.
The concrete individual work with pupils was associated with the organization of several cultural and sportive activities, where participated not only the 110 pupils subject of the Project, but also other pupils of the school, who were distinguished in such activities.

During the period of Project implementation and onward, various progress analysis have been carried out about the problems faced in reaching the defined objectives. These analysis have played an important role in the continuous progress made at this school.

Hence, some good results have been reached regarding both indicators: 16 pupils were withdrawn from working and  turned back to school, two of them had surpassed the age of compulsary education, while two females continue to have problems with their parents, because of their age and physical growth.
Better results were achieved with the pupils who were at risk to drop out. From the 94 pupils at the very beginning, 68 of them were totally integrated at school, 14 pupils had made evident progress, while 12 pupils were still having problems with their results at school.

The basis of these achievements was the concrete individual work done with pupils by teachers and other stakeholders. But food packages that were delivered with the financial assistance of Dutch Trade Union, FNV, had a direct impact. Even though very symbolic, they were a good support to teachers’ and pupils’ work and had a great impact on many families of Roma people community.

Bathore, in Tirana neighbourhood, second semester of 2010,  
supported by ILO-IPEC

Bathore, in Tirana neighbourhood, is one of the biggest informal areas in Albania, created after the change of former system in 1991. It has got about 30 000 inhabitants, most of them living in poverty.
Two primary schools, with about 2897 pupils and 180 teachers operate in this area.

More than 120 pupils who had dropped out and were working, or were at risk of dropping out, were the target of this project. More than 45 teachers, pupils, leaders of local trade unions, representatives of local government and non governmental organizations of this area, were involved and worked concretely with the pupils and their parents for convincing them to turn back to school.

Four monitoring groups, composed of 22 teachers, pupils and parents were established and functioned within the framework of this Project. They paid more than 130 visits in pupils’ families, discussing with their parents and working individually with each of them, also taking into consideration the individual pecularities of each pupil.
As a result of this hard work, 101 pupils ( 59 males and 42 females) were withdrawn fro working and turned back to school, or were rescued from dropping out, while the others were provided with non formal education and complementary services, taking account of their individual and family conditions.

Korca, August 2010 and onward, supported by AOb, Holland

There are 15 873 pupils enrolled and 1 040 teachers employed at the primary education system in Korca district.
Only at “Asdreni” and “ Naim Frasheri” schools, where the work of our two trade unions is focused, during the school year 2010-2011, 89 pupils had dropped out and were working. In addition, there were 420 pupils at risk to drop out, who missed several classes in a day or even several days in a week, working during the missing days / hours, before or after the school lessons.
Most of these pupils were from Roma or Egyptian communities. For example, at “Naim Frasheri” school, out of 359 pupils in total, 345 come from these communities. Their parents have a low educational level and their families face many financial problems, being in the threshold of survival conditions.
Eight Monitoring groups, composed of 48, teachers, pupils and parents involved almost all teachers of both schools and other pupils and parents, to deal with more than 500 pupils that had dropped out or were at risk of dropping out.

Local leaders of both trade unions, representatives of school administrations, local government and organizations of civil society, Korca Regional Education Directorate etc, were directly involved in the implementation of the project.

As a result of the concrete work done in the framework of this Project implementation, 52 pupils out of 89 who had dropped out, were withdrawn from working and turned back to school, while 256 pupils out of 420 who were at risk to drop out, were totally integrated and improved their results at school.

Being directly supported by the Dutch Education Trade Union, AOb, the work is going on and other positive results are expected to be reached, not only at these two schools, but also at other schools of this district, which might get involved in such projects in the future.
Our experience shows that it is very important to keep in mind that organizing seminars, round tables or other forms of training dealing theoretically with these issues is not sufficient; they should also be associated with measurable objectives and concrete individual work with pupils who have dropped out, work or are at risk of dropping out.
A positive impact has had the provision of school materials for 40 pupils from each of these schools, which was enabled for two years in succession through the financial support of Dutch Education Trade Union, AOb.

 

 

Some practical guidelines

about the comittment of education trade unions

on child labour prevention and elimination

 

The experience shows that to sucessfully reduce drop outs, prevent and eliminate child labour, we should take into consideration the main directions of education’ trade unions work:

  1. Leaders on all levels, including school trade unions, should have a better understanding of the fact that committment to keep pupils at school, prevent and eliminate child labour, are very important trade union issues, since they are related, not only to the education of all children and progressive development of the society, but also to the role and functioning of trade unions themsleves, which are important partners of the Ministry of Education and Science and other educational institutions.
  2. It is very important to include the issue of prevention and elimination of child labour in the agenda of each trade union, as its priorities, together with protection of social-economic interests of its members, improvement of working conditions and other issues directly related to trade unions mission. This requires a better acquaintance of the situation, identification of schools and pupils facing drop outs and low level of syllabus comprehension, and defining the measures that should be taken by the leading bodies of trade unions as to organization of activities and involving both teachers and pupils in concrete actions for the improvement of the situation.
  3. Another important step in this process is taking measures as to training of leaders, teachers and activists of teachers’ trade unions, including members of Monitoring Groups,who will be directly engaged in carryiyng out this work on all levels, through seminars, workshops, round tables etc, as a precondition and efficient support for reaching the objectives of these projects and programs.

Seminars and other activities should be focused on the following issues:.

- International standards and legal framework as to prevention and elimination of child labour; how to get better acquainted with and how to implement them, (United Nations Convention on Child Rights, ILO Convention No. 138 on Minimum Age, ratified by Albania in 1999, and the respective Recommendation, ILO Convention No. 182 on the Worst Forms of Child Labour, ratified by Albania in 2001, and the respective Recommendation, Decision of Council of Ministers on the List of Dangerous Jobs etc.).

-The real situation of child labour in Albania and the role of education trade unions in cooperation with governmental institutions, ILO-IPEC and Albanian NGO’s interested in these issues as to prevention of child labour.

- Causes of child labour, as to demand and supply, impacts of child labour on the child himself, his/her family and society.

- Coordination and collaboration with school administrations, local government, parents and community for preventing and eliminating child labour.

- Teachers’ individual work with problematic pupils, ( those who don’t have good results at school, are at risk to drop out, have got problems with their parents who might have been sued to court, who have lost one of the parents or have neither of them, as well as children from Roma and Egyptian communities), by dealing individually with concretecases in the respective districts.

The following organising measures should be taken to reach the objectives set within this frame:                                                                                              

- Take adequate measures to get acquainted with the real situation and define the objectives for its improvement.  To this aim, it is necessary to develop questionaries with detailed data about pupils who have dropped out and are working, as well as about those that are at risk of dropping out, which are the causes of this situation, which is the economic situation of their families, which is their parents behaviour etc, and developing individual plans for each targeted pupil, based on these data.

- Establishing and making functional the Monitoring Groups, on two levels:                                     

- on district level with the participation of representatives from trade union section, Education Directorate, local government, parents and pupils, non governmental organizations dealing with these issues and;                                                                                                          

on school level, composed of teachers, pupils, parents and representatives of school administration etc.                                                                             

These groups constitute the cores which bring together the most active and deligent teachers who define the concrete actions that should be taken regarding the pupils who have dropped out or are at risk of, consisting in:

a. Organization of public discussions with teachers involved and selected pupils, aiming at discovering the causes of drop outs and working individually with every pupil, to find out their problems, family needs and define the methods that should be used for returning back and integrating them to school.

b. Tutoring pupils who have dropped out or are at risk to, by teachers and pupils who will be directly engaged in this work,

c. Develop questionaires  with all required data about each target pupil and cooperate with tutoring teachers about issues related to continuation of teaching process and pupils’ progress.

d. Working together with pupils’ government and parents’ committee, for assisting target pupils by also involving the best pupils in the respective classes.

e. Undertaking concrete and individual actions with pupils who have dropped out or are at risk to, especially dealing with those who are actually working, their parents and relatives, in cases when there are efforts to drop them out of school. It is important that teachers, pupils and all those committed to work in groups or individually, should use the adequate arguments to convince, not only the children but also their parents and relatives about the indispensability of education, since it is important, not only for the child’s prospect development, but also for his/her family which is responsible for his/her education and preparation to face the challenges of the future. It is also important for the entire society which cannot develop and prosper without educated people, capable to successfully meet time requirements and challenges of the future.

f. Organization of cultural, artistic and sportive activities with the participation of all target pupils, aiming at making school and learning as attractive as possible for each of them.

g. Working closely with local government about these issues as to finding out any job opportunities or food aids for extreme cases.

h. Of particular importance is the coordination of all this work with school Directories and Regional Education Directorates in the respective districts.

An important part of this collaboration is the inclusion of issues related to minimization of drop outs and elimination of child labour in the collective agreement of second level, based on Article 10 of the Collective Agreement of the first level already in power, where the obligations of parties are well defined.

Massive use of publications produced by education trade unions such as:  ILO-ACTRAV Manual, “Trade Unions and Child Labour”, “SCREAM” Modules, the Manual “Teaching and Learning in the Informal Education”, as well as divulgation of achieved results and best experiences through communication means, TV channels, newspapers etc.

There is no doubt that the organization of all these activities requires very powerful trade unions, experience and sufficient financial means. Hence, trainers, dedicated activists as well as financial sources can be found if there is close collaboration between central trade union presidencies and district sections to organize training seminars, workshops and other qualification courses for the people who are involved directly with activities for preventing and eliminating child labour, developing discussions about these issues or exchanging experience etc.

But, there exist other opportunities for raising sufficient funds from various domestic or foreign donators, by developing concrete projects about reducing drop outs, preventing and eliminating child labour.
To this aim, we should get better acquainted with and benefit from various  International and European Organizations actually operating in our country such as: European Commission, International Labour Organization  (ILO), USAID, UNICEF, Soros Foundation,  Fridrih Ebert Foundation etc.
We might be successful in providing financial support for these projects on school or district level also by navigating into their web pages and benefiting from the intermediary role of FSASH and SPASH leadership.

 

 

EXTRACTS FROM THE COLLECTIVE AGREEMENT OF
FSASH/SPASH WITH THE MINISTRY OF EDUCATION AND SCIENCE
2010-2014        

                                                   

Article 10
COMMITTMENT FOR REDUCING DROP OUTS AND
ELIMINATION OF CHILD LABOUR

10.1 Both education trade unions, FSASH and SPASH, should be committed for the reduction of drop outs and elimination of child labour, using their own resources, as well as other support, especially from Education International, EI, other homologue trade unions and so on.

10.2. By training the leaders and members of trade unions and using various concrete forms of work at school and in the community, they aim at increasing the number of teachers working with pupils who drop out or are at risk to, by creating an attractive and parental environment for the elimination of child labour.

10.3. The Ministry of Education and Science, considering it as one of its strategic priorities, supports this committment and guarantees the willingness of school administrations to undertake joint actions, by promoting and involving both pupils and parents’ forums, as well.

10.4.  Proposed by signers of the Collective Agreement, FSASH and SPASH, the Regional Educational Directorates remunerate, from the special fund, the teachers who have been directly involved and reached measurable results as to the reduction of drop outs and elimination of child labour.